Cleveland Heights Mainstay Tommy’s Restaurant Gains National Spotlight After Five Decades
Tommy’s Restaurant, a fixture of the Coventry Village neighborhood in Cleveland Heights since 1972, is receiving renewed national attention more than 50 years after its founding. Known for its inclusive menu and counter-culture roots, the restaurant continues to draw crowds for its signature milkshakes and falafel, cementing its status as a local institution even as the surrounding district evolves.
Deep Roots in Coventry
The story of Tommy’s began when current owner Tommy Fello started working as a soda jerk at a local drug store on Coventry Road in the late 1960s. By 1972, Fello had purchased the business, transforming it into a full-service restaurant that reflected the neighborhood’s bohemian spirit. Unlike many establishments of the era, Tommy’s was an early adopter of dietary inclusivity, offering extensive vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options long before they became industry standards. This foresight helped the restaurant cultivate a fiercely loyal customer base that spans generations.
Enduring Appeal Amidst Change
While the national recognition highlights the restaurant’s longevity and beloved menu—ranging from the famous spins on grilled cheese to the thick, hand-spun milkshakes—local context adds layers to the story. The Coventry Village neighborhood has faced significant economic shifts, with periods of vibrant nightlife giving way to struggles with retail vacancies and foot traffic in recent years. Longtime patrons often cite parking challenges and the closure of other legacy businesses as points of friction for the area. However, Tommy’s has managed to weather these neighborhood fluctuations, surviving fires and relocations within the same block to remain a stable anchor for the community.
A Menu Built on Community
Part of the restaurant’s unique character comes from its menu design, where many items are named after the regular customers who originally ordered them. This personalized approach has created a sense of ownership among patrons, although some critics argue that the extensive, text-heavy menu can be overwhelming for newcomers. Additionally, while the restaurant preserves a nostalgic price point relative to fine dining, rising operational costs have inevitably impacted menu prices, a common reality for mom-and-pop operations nationwide. Despite these industry-wide challenges, the recent national spotlight underscores the rarity of a family-owned spot thriving for over half a century in a constantly changing culinary landscape.
clevescene.com
coolcleveland.com
clevescene.com
