Sonder’s Philly Collapse Scramble: Witherspoon Building Pivots to Long-Term Rentals as Competitors Eye Leftovers
The rapid disintegration of Sonder Holdings has triggered a major real estate reshuffle in Philadelphia, with landlords moving swiftly to reclaim properties and stabilize assets left in limbo by the hospitality firm’s bankruptcy. In the most significant development to date, the owners of the Witherspoon Building at 130 S. Juniper Street have confirmed they are abandoning the short-term rental model entirely, repositioning the 186-unit historic high-rise as traditional apartments.
SSH Real Estate, which owns the Witherspoon in partnership with Young Capital, announced the strategic pivot this week. The firm has begun marketing the former “apartment-hotels” as standard studio, one-, and two-bedroom residences, signaling a retreat from the volatility of the hospitality sector. “We are optimistic about the future of the building as a residential property,” stated Andrew Walheim, Vice President of Investments at SSH, emphasizing a return to stability over the high-risk arbitrage of short-term stays.
This transition marks the first major domino to fall in the local market following Sonder’s catastrophic collapse in late 2025. The San Francisco-based company, once valued at over $2 billion, filed for Chapter 7 liquidation in November after Marriott International terminated a critical licensing agreement due to default. The fallout was immediate and chaotic: guests at the Witherspoon and other Philadelphia locations, such as The Arco on Locust Street and The Queen Hotel in Queen Village, were reportedly given less than 24 hours to vacate, leaving travelers stranded and landlords with empty buildings.
Deep Search: The Scramble for Leases
While SSH is opting for traditional tenants, other former Sonder sites may yet remain in the hospitality circuit. Gordon Brothers, a restructuring firm, has been tasked with marketing Sonder’s leasehold interests nationwide. Concurrently, Kasa Living, a tech-enabled hospitality operator, has emerged as a potential savior for some of these distressed assets. Kasa CEO Roman Pedan confirmed the company is in active discussions with property owners in Philadelphia to take over management, having already acquired a dozen former Sonder locations in other markets.
However, the path to acquisition is fraught with financial debris. The sale of The Edison, a 24-unit luxury property at 312 N. 2nd Street in Old City, highlights the complexity. The building was sold for nearly $10 million in a deal brokered by GREA just prior to the total collapse, with a master lease that is now effectively worthless. New owners across the city are now forced to choose between renegotiating with operators like Kasa—often on less favorable terms than Sonder’s venture-capital-backed promises—or incurring the capital costs to convert units for long-term residential use.
Objections and Market Skepticism
The swift pivot at the Witherspoon has emboldened critics of the “master lease” business model, where companies like Sonder and the defunct WeWork sign long-term leases to sublet space for short-term profits. Market analysts describe the model as an “economic weapon of mass destruction” during downturns, noting that it leaves landlords with zero revenue the moment the operator fails.
Local real estate observers remain skeptical that other operators can succeed where Sonder failed. “The operational overhead in Philadelphia is high, and without the artificially inflated rents Sonder was paying to capture market share, the numbers simply don’t pencil out for many landlords,” noted one local commercial broker. There are also concerns regarding tenant trust; the reputational damage from the November evictions may deter travelers from booking “tech-hotel” accommodations in the near term, making the traditional apartment route chosen by SSH appear the only safe harbor.
Background: The Unicorn That Failed
Sonder’s implosion is the latest cautionary tale of the “growth at all costs” era. Founded in Montreal in 2014, the company sought to disrupt the hospitality industry by leasing apartments and running them like hotels, but without the on-site staff. Despite going public in 2022, Sonder struggled to achieve profitability. Its final lifeline—a partnership with Marriott intended to integrate Sonder units into the Bonvoy booking system—failed due to technical integration delays and Sonder’s inability to meet financial obligations.
For Philadelphia, the liquidation effectively ends a brief, venture-fueled experiment in mass-scale corporate short-term rentals, returning iconic buildings like the Witherspoon to the hands of local residents.
philadelphia.today
hotelrealtor.biz
phillyvoice.com
bisnow.com
inquirer.com
