Chester County Officials Acknowledge New Election Mailer Error Following Year of Voting Turmoil
Chester County election officials confirmed this week that a printing error affected recent mail-in ballot applications, marking the latest in a series of administrative missteps that have left some residents questioning the integrity of the local voting process.
Deep Search: The Latest Incident
The most recent error involves mail-in ballot applications sent to voters where first and last names were inadvertently reversed. County officials stated that the mistake was a vendor printing issue and have moved quickly to assure the public that the error is cosmetic. According to a county spokesperson, the reversal of names will not hinder the processing of applications or the ability of voters to receive their ballots. The bar codes and voter identification numbers on the forms remain accurate, allowing the election bureau to scan and process the requests without interruption.
This incident comes at a sensitive time for the county’s Voter Services department, which is still reeling from a significant operational failure during the November 2025 general election. In that event, a “clerical error” resulted in the omission of approximately 75,000 third-party and unaffiliated voters from the printed poll books at all 230 precincts. The oversight forced thousands of voters to cast provisional ballots and led a judge to extend voting hours until 10 p.m. to accommodate the confusion.
Objections and Official Response
County officials argue that the current printing error is minor and fundamentally different from the poll book exclusion of 2025. They emphasize that no voter is being disenfranchised and that the safeguards in place—specifically the unique barcodes on the mailers—are functioning as intended to prevent any disruption to the election timeline.
Regarding the 2025 poll book error, an independent investigation conducted by the law firm Fleck Eckert Klein McGarry concluded that the failure was not intentional. The report, released in early 2026, attributed the chaos to “simple human error” compounded by inadequate training and a lack of institutional safeguards. Investigators found that two inexperienced employees had mistakenly selected a setting to include only major-party voters when generating the poll book files, a mistake that went undetected due to a lack of multi-level verification protocols.
The investigation’s findings have been used by the county to refute claims of partisan tampering. “This appears to be a human error in clicking a wrong box,” said attorney Sigmund Fleck, representing the firm behind the inquiry. County Commissioner Josh Maxwell has also publicly apologized, stating, “If we make a mistake, we have to remedy it,” and has pledged to implement a 14-point action plan to overhaul internal oversight.
Background Info: A Pattern of Concern
Despite these assurances, the repeated technical glitches have fueled skepticism among the electorate. During the certification of the November 2025 results, tensions ran high, with Commissioner Eric Roe voting against certification and noting that his “confidence in the administration of the elections in Chester County is shaken.”
Residents have expressed similar sentiments in public meetings, with some calling for the resignation of Voter Services leadership. The frustration is compounded by the volume of provisional ballots cast in the last election—over 12,000—which is significantly higher than historical averages for the county. While the vast majority of those provisional ballots were eventually counted, the delay and confusion at polling places created a lasting impression of instability.
The county’s new remedial plan includes dual-signature approval for poll book generation, enhanced staff training, and stricter vendor oversight. However, with this latest mailer mix-up occurring just months after the department promised rigorous reforms, officials face a renewed challenge in rebuilding public trust before the next major election cycle.
youtube.com
chestercounty.com
whyy.org
whyy.org
spotlightpa.org
votebeat.org
youtube.com
vista.today
