They became ‘chosen brothers’ in a maximum-security prison. Then one got out.
For decades, Scott “Slim” Harmon and Mark Williams navigated the brutal realities of life inside a Pennsylvania maximum-security prison together, forging a bond that transcended mere friendship to become what they call “chosen brotherhood.” That dynamic shifted abruptly last April when Harmon’s murder conviction was overturned, leading to his release. Now, despite their enduring connection, a Pennsylvania Department of Corrections policy stands as a concrete wall between them, prohibiting the two men from seeing each other in person.
Deep Search
The core of their current struggle lies in a specific Department of Corrections regulation that restricts visitation rights for former inmates. While Harmon is now a free man, having been exonerated after his conviction was vacated, his status as a formerly incarcerated individual complicates his ability to return to the facility as a visitor. Harmon and Williams still communicate daily via phone calls, maintaining the emotional lifeline that sustained them for years, but the inability to meet face-to-face highlights a systemic barrier often overlooked in conversations about prisoner reentry. The policy effectively treats the bond that helped them survive incarceration as a potential security risk once one party is released.
Add Objections
Corrections officials argue that such policies are essential for maintaining order and security within penal institutions. Restricting visits from former inmates is a standard practice designed to prevent the introduction of contraband and to disrupt potential criminal networks or gang affiliations that may extend beyond prison walls. From an administrative perspective, the “chosen brother” dynamic, while emotionally significant to the individuals, can be viewed as a potential vector for illicit coordination. There is also the argument that a clean break from prison associates is necessary for a released individual’s successful reintegration into society, minimizing the risk of recidivism by severing ties with the incarcerated population.
Add Background Info
The concept of “chosen family” is prevalent in long-term incarceration scenarios, where inmates often fill the void of absent biological family members with close-knit peer support networks. These relationships are frequently cited by psychologists as critical for mental health and survival in high-stress prison environments. Harmon’s release following an overturned conviction places him in a specific statistical category of exonerated individuals who face unique reentry challenges—not just finding housing and employment, but navigating the sudden loss of their primary support system left behind bars. Pennsylvania’s strict visitation policies reflect a broader national tension between security protocols and the humane recognition of the deep, rehabilitative bonds formed during incarceration.
inquirer.com
inquirer.com
