ChatGPT Analysis: Philadelphians Are ‘Annoying’ but Own ‘Iconic’ Brand and Sandwich Scene
New research from the University of Oxford and the University of Kentucky has forced ChatGPT to reveal its hidden biases about U.S. cities, delivering a mixed verdict on Philadelphia: the artificial intelligence views the city’s residents as “annoying,” yet praises its “iconic branding” and undisputed dominance in the sandwich category.
Deep Search: The ‘Silicon Gaze’ Methodology
The findings come from a broader study titled The Silicon Gaze, conducted by the Oxford Internet Institute. Researchers sought to bypass ChatGPT’s standard safety filters—which typically refuse to answer subjective questions like “Who is lazier?”—by systematically forcing the model to choose between two options repeatedly. By running millions of these “forced choice” scenarios, the team exposed the underlying statistical associations embedded in the AI’s training data.
According to the analysis, ChatGPT ranked Philadelphia highly on the “annoying” scale, a reflection of the internet-scraped text the model was trained on. However, the AI also exhibited a strong positive bias toward the city’s commercial and cultural identity, specifically highlighting its “iconic branding” and sandwich culture. This duality illustrates what researchers call the “Silicon Gaze”—a phenomenon where AI reproduces and amplifies existing internet stereotypes rather than providing neutral assessments.
Background: A Reputation Built on Passion and Pork
The “annoying” label likely stems from decades of national media coverage focusing on Philadelphia’s boisterous sports culture. The city’s reputation is frequently tied to events like the 1968 incident where Eagles fans threw snowballs at Santa Claus, or the more recent tradition of greasing light poles to prevent fans from climbing them after championships.
Conversely, the “best sandwiches” accolade aligns with Philadelphia’s culinary reality. While the cheesesteak is the most globally recognized export, the city is equally famous among food critics for its roast pork sandwiches (often featuring broccoli rabe and sharp provolone) and hoagies. The “iconic branding” mentioned likely refers to the city’s successful integration of its colonial history (The Liberty Bell, Independence Hall) with its gritty, underdog pop-culture image (the Rocky franchise), creating a globally recognizable identity that the AI’s algorithms easily latch onto.
Objections: Passion vs. Annoyance
Local defenders argue that the “annoying” label is a misinterpretation of what Philadelphians consider “passionate” and “authentic.” Residents often pride themselves on a lack of pretense, viewing their direct communication style as a virtue rather than a vice.
Critics of the study—and the AI’s conclusions—point out that labeling a population “annoying” is a subjective judgment that often targets working-class cities with distinct dialects and strong local cultures. Furthermore, reducing the city’s complex identity to “sandwiches and sports noise” ignores its booming biotech sector, vast mural arts program, and status as a UNESCO World Heritage City. As the study authors note, these AI biases are not objective truths but rather a mirror of the most dominant, and often loudest, voices on the internet.
uky.edu
ox.ac.uk
ox.ac.uk
washingtonpost.com
