Pennsylvania Governor Shapiro Balances Federal ICE Criticism With State Cooperation Policies
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro finds himself navigating a precarious political divide regarding immigration enforcement, intensifying his rhetoric against federal operations while maintaining state-level cooperation with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
The Democratic governor has become increasingly vocal following fatal shootings by federal agents in Minneapolis, an event that resulted in the death of activist Alex Pretti. Shapiro and members of his cabinet recently signed a letter characterizing the federal agency’s tactics as a “clear abuse of power” and a disregard for established law enforcement protocols. This marks a shift for Shapiro, who had largely avoided direct confrontations over immigration policy during the early months of the current federal administration.
Despite these public condemnations, Shapiro faces significant objections from immigrant rights advocates and progressive groups within Pennsylvania. Critics argue that the governor’s administration continues to facilitate the very operations he publicly decries. The Pennsylvania Department of Corrections currently honors ICE detainers, holding individuals for federal agents beyond their scheduled release dates. Furthermore, the state allows the federal agency access to Commonwealth databases, a practice that advocates say assists in the targeting of undocumented residents.
“It is easy for him to point the finger to somebody else, but then what is he doing at home?” one local advocate remarked, highlighting the discrepancy between Shapiro’s national statements and his domestic policies.
Shapiro has steadfastly maintained that Pennsylvania is “not a sanctuary state,” distinguishing his administration’s stance from local jurisdictions like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, which have enacted specific sanctuary policies limiting police cooperation with ICE. This distinction allows the governor to defend the state’s eligibility for federal funding, which the White House has threatened to withhold from sanctuary jurisdictions. In a move illustrating this friction, Shapiro recently criticized Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner for comparing ICE agents to Nazis, a comment that further complicates the intra-party dynamic.
The governor’s office states it is preparing for potential immigration enforcement raids within the Commonwealth, though specific details on these preparations remain undisclosed. Shapiro emphasizes that his priority remains public safety and the rule of law, attempting to hold a middle ground between resisting federal overreach and enforcing existing state protocols.
inquirer.com
post-gazette.com
spotlightpa.org
